Property Management Services

Full-service management designed to protect your property and maximize your rental income.

List your property

Complete Rental Management That Protects Your Property & Grows Your Revenue

At Property Management of Hayward, Inc., we provide full-service rental property management throughout Sawyer, Bayfield, Douglas, and Washburn counties—helping owners earn more while doing less.

Whether you own a lakefront cabin, a vacation home, or an investment property, we handle the day-to-day work so you don’t have to.

If you're considering renting your property and want to understand its income potential, we’d be happy to meet, walk your property, and offer professional guidance on next steps.

List your property

A Proud Member of the Community Since 1995

Since 1995, Property Management of Hayward, Inc. has been part of the fabric of the Hayward area—trusted by local homeowners, second-home owners, and rental property investors. As a locally owned business, we understand the unique demands of managing Northwoods rentals, from seasonal fluctuations to guest expectations and property care.

For nearly three decades, we've helped owners protect their investments, reduce stress, and generate reliable rental income. Our longevity comes from what owners value most: consistency, communication, and care.

We treat every property as if it were our own—because we’re not just a management company, we’re your neighbors, invested in the success and future of the Hayward community.

Innovative Marketing with Cutting-Edge Technology

We combine local expertise with modern technology to deliver better results for rental owners. Using advanced property management software, dynamic pricing tools, and real-time performance tracking, we ensure your property is always optimized for maximum visibility and revenue.

Your listing is professionally marketed across all major platforms—Airbnb, Vrbo, Booking.com, Google Vacation Rentals, and more—reaching the right guests at the right time. With high-quality listings, strategic pricing, and proactive reputation management, we minimize vacancies and boost your earnings while keeping your property competitive in today's market.

In short: your property works smarter, performs stronger, and stays booked more often.

First Call to Final Farewell

We handle every aspect of guest communication, so you never have to deal with late-night messages or complicated requests. From the first inquiry to check-out and follow-up, our team ensures guests feel supported, informed, and welcomed—leading to more 5-star reviews, better visibility, and repeat bookings.

Whether it’s sending check-in instructions, solving issues quickly, or coordinating special requests, we create a smooth, stress-free experience that reflects positively on your property and protects your investment.

What other property owners are saying…

  • Highly recommended!

    We've been working with Dustin and the folks at PMH Vacation Rentals for over 15 years. They are professional, positive and always eager to help. Many of the rentals they provide are pet friendly which works well for us since we have two black labs. PMH ensures everything is ready when you arrive at your rental. Someone is always available to help if a problem does come up. My family and I have never been disappointed in the service and follow up provided by PMH. We will continue to use them now and in the future when planning our family vacations. I highly recommend PMH and personally feel they are the best rental agency in the greater Hayward area.

    Kurt Rasmussen

  • Fantastic partner in renting our cabin!

    Property Management of Hayward has been a fantastic partner in renting our cabin on Little Spider Lake. Dustin always goes the extra mile to answer my questions, help out when needed and make sure our property is in tip-top shape for anyone who rents. We built our property just last year and he was instrumental in making sure we were perfectly stocked and ready to go. So glad we have PMH on our side to represent Eagle’s Landing on Little Spider Lake. They are a class operation.

    Jeff Nowak

  • Highly responsive to guests and owners

    PMH has managed our guest home (Bluewater Memories) on Round Lake in Hayward WI, for 16 years. They are highly responsive to guests and owners alike. We are very happy with Dustin and have only received positive feedback from renters over the years. Highly recommended!

    Tim Coats

Turn your cabin or lake home into a high-performing rental with hands-off, full-service care.

We’re here to help.

List your property